I recently climbed electric cowboy (awesome route) and had a bitch of a time cleaning the route because of the rat's nest of slings that have been added so that quick links will hang from the bolts over the ledge to the face. I would have replaced the slings, but was unprepared for such a crummy anchor on a sport climb.
What are the ethics on replacing the slings with some chain link? I'm willing to foot the bill, hike out there, and replace the slings with chain and quick links. Any concerns from the community? I couldn't think of any off hand but I thought I'd put it out there first.
Also, I've heard there can be issues between using plated steel in combination with stainless. Since I've never replaced any part of an anchor before I wanted to make sure I didn't cause un-intended damage. Is there a standard set-up that is becoming popular in the Red that I could use?
electric cowboy
-
marathonmedic
- Posts: 1557
- Joined: Fri Feb 20, 2004 3:01 am
I don't think there would be any problem from the community if you're replacing mank with something a bit more reliable. I haven't seen the anchor setup, but would it be a better situation for some new anchors in a new place instead of having chains running over the edge? How sharp is that ledge?
Ticking is gym climbing outdoors.
-
michaelarmand
- Posts: 527
- Joined: Fri Mar 23, 2007 1:08 pm
If the bolts are good I saw just re-do the rig with new webbing and rap rings. The problem with chains over an edge is that they erode the rock into a deep groove, kinda like if a rope was repeatedly run over an edge. Think back to the chains atop Bedtime For Bonzo. I can't quite remember the top of EC, but would moving the position of the anchor take away from the last exciting moves?
I see they are still lopping off mountains in Eastern Kentucky. Electricity isn't cheap.
-
absolutsugarsmurf
- Posts: 96
- Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 1:03 am
Replacing the quick links with rap rings on slings/webbing would be an easy and cheap alternative. However, the final moves on EC are always exposed to sun. I’m afraid the webbing would deteriorate due to excess UV exposure. The webbing currently there is looking weathered and feels stiff.
The exiting moves would not drastically be altered if the anchor was moved to the face and were kept short, without chain link, perhaps rap anchors instead of bolts. There should be a reason for where they are located though, John B was the F.A. and his judgment on the situation was likely more sound than mine is. Perhaps someone else can speak more knowledgeably on this matter. Besides, moving the anchors is out of the realm of my capabilities and is something I do not feel comfortable attempting. Maybe someone else does. Let me know if you want to, I’ll pay for the hardware, If it is a lawfull act in the NF (teamsuck?).
Webbing wears grooves in rock too. I really don't see a difference. Is there evidence of webbing being less abrasive than chain?
The exiting moves would not drastically be altered if the anchor was moved to the face and were kept short, without chain link, perhaps rap anchors instead of bolts. There should be a reason for where they are located though, John B was the F.A. and his judgment on the situation was likely more sound than mine is. Perhaps someone else can speak more knowledgeably on this matter. Besides, moving the anchors is out of the realm of my capabilities and is something I do not feel comfortable attempting. Maybe someone else does. Let me know if you want to, I’ll pay for the hardware, If it is a lawfull act in the NF (teamsuck?).
Webbing wears grooves in rock too. I really don't see a difference. Is there evidence of webbing being less abrasive than chain?
Chain heavy. Webbing light. Chain hard metal. Webbing soft fabric.absolutsugarsmurf wrote:I really don't see a difference. Is there evidence of webbing being less abrasive than chain?
Looks like scientific evidence to me. I just remember the grooves the chain on Bedtime wore into the rock, it left a deeper groove in a shorter time than the webbing did. If people would properly replace the webbing and rings on anchors as needed things would be fine. Wasn't there a study finding that UV doesn't weaken webbing as much as previous thought? Of course bolt anchors and chains with a camo paint job are less visible than day glow yellow webbing. I guess I really don't care, whatever the bolting fairies decide is best sounds fine to me.
we are planning a 9a/b rebolt weekend soon. if your interested in hanging ropes, carrying gear and even drilling some let me know and we will figure out a team weekend to get out there. 9a/b area will be a pet project this winter instead of bolting new routes.
http://www.redriveroutdoors.com
If you need to contact me , email me. Less Internet, less stress
If you need to contact me , email me. Less Internet, less stress