Route comments / Cock fights / Route Grades
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 4:00 pm
I find that the route comments section of the online guide is a fantastic tool for beta, safety tips, location, personal perspective, etc. One of the most useful parts of the entire site.
What drives me crazy is the cock fights that erupt absolutely EVERY time someone questions the route grade in the comments section. The petty back and forth comments (often fueled by someone) end up making honest/helpful assessments of the climb difficult to find. Who wants to wade through all that mindless venom for a few gems?
The problem comes from the combination of ego climbers(climbers whose purpose is conquering high grades, not just climbing b/c it's fun and fascinating) and the inherent ambiguity of route grading system.
As it would be impossible to eliminate either of these two factors i suggest the route grading comments be eliminated from the route comments section . Afterall one can always input the rating one thinks is appropriate. And the someone's out there should be allowed neither comment or route grading.
What drives me crazy is the cock fights that erupt absolutely EVERY time someone questions the route grade in the comments section. The petty back and forth comments (often fueled by someone) end up making honest/helpful assessments of the climb difficult to find. Who wants to wade through all that mindless venom for a few gems?
The problem comes from the combination of ego climbers(climbers whose purpose is conquering high grades, not just climbing b/c it's fun and fascinating) and the inherent ambiguity of route grading system.
As it would be impossible to eliminate either of these two factors i suggest the route grading comments be eliminated from the route comments section . Afterall one can always input the rating one thinks is appropriate. And the someone's out there should be allowed neither comment or route grading.