missing routes in the new guidebook
Posted: Fri Sep 09, 2005 10:19 pm
I checked out the new guide today and I am majorly impressed. There aren't many guidebooks that can rise to the level that Ray has done with this one. I especially like all the route photos for obscure trad lines, especially as a climber who almost solely seeks out the obscure lines. Those photos sure would have saved me a lot of time and confusion in the past. I was wondering though why there were a few routes left out. I'm not talking Closed areas like Pocket or Oil Crack, or obscure areas like Rock Bridge and Meyers, but routes at areas in the new book.
I'm going to take a stab at answering my own question - all of them are obscure, no doubt and a few like Sampsel's Dihedral are nearly impossible to find. Also I'm going to say they didn't make the cut because they were toprope routes (Dead Deer, Mantelpiece) or chopped (Trouble, Day Dreams and Nightmares - which can now be done as a TR once climbing Lunatic Fringe). The toprope routes seem like they should have made the cut since other TRs did, but in those cases, it looked like space might have been the real issue. Other routes, like Tower Rock Pinnacle definitly should have been included. Don't take that as criticism Ray, I was just curious and I'm a nerd so I notice stupid shit like that. Excellent job!
I'm going to take a stab at answering my own question - all of them are obscure, no doubt and a few like Sampsel's Dihedral are nearly impossible to find. Also I'm going to say they didn't make the cut because they were toprope routes (Dead Deer, Mantelpiece) or chopped (Trouble, Day Dreams and Nightmares - which can now be done as a TR once climbing Lunatic Fringe). The toprope routes seem like they should have made the cut since other TRs did, but in those cases, it looked like space might have been the real issue. Other routes, like Tower Rock Pinnacle definitly should have been included. Don't take that as criticism Ray, I was just curious and I'm a nerd so I notice stupid shit like that. Excellent job!