Sustainable route development
Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2008 6:57 am
A few questions and thoughts running around my head.
Although the gorge potential sometimes seems endless, new routes are clearly a finite resource experiencing accelerated consumption. First question: How many quality routes do you think are left to develop? are we 2/3 tapped, 1/2, 1/4? Maybe this was a poll I missed a long time ago, but I'd be psyched to see a recap. Second question: Is this a resource that we as a climbing community should seek to preserve? It is a uniquely satisfying experience to find a piece of rock, envision the line, discover holds and sequences, design a logical way of protecting it, clean, drill, work and send. It is such a rich experience compared to walking up to an established, chalked crag and climbing a route. As route developers we give time and money, but we also take something very precious: the unclimbed line. Are we being greedy by developing at the pace that we are? Should we consider the next generation of climbers (not just the 5.16 climbers) and work to preserve the opportunity for them to share these rewarding experiences?
I guess this seems a bit unrealistic at the community level, but if I ever have the chance to live in KY again, these thoughts might help me prioritize my own climbing activities. It seems like the analogy to other finite resources like oil is not so far fetched and it would be a shame to not learn something from our mistakes.
What are your thoughts?
Although the gorge potential sometimes seems endless, new routes are clearly a finite resource experiencing accelerated consumption. First question: How many quality routes do you think are left to develop? are we 2/3 tapped, 1/2, 1/4? Maybe this was a poll I missed a long time ago, but I'd be psyched to see a recap. Second question: Is this a resource that we as a climbing community should seek to preserve? It is a uniquely satisfying experience to find a piece of rock, envision the line, discover holds and sequences, design a logical way of protecting it, clean, drill, work and send. It is such a rich experience compared to walking up to an established, chalked crag and climbing a route. As route developers we give time and money, but we also take something very precious: the unclimbed line. Are we being greedy by developing at the pace that we are? Should we consider the next generation of climbers (not just the 5.16 climbers) and work to preserve the opportunity for them to share these rewarding experiences?
I guess this seems a bit unrealistic at the community level, but if I ever have the chance to live in KY again, these thoughts might help me prioritize my own climbing activities. It seems like the analogy to other finite resources like oil is not so far fetched and it would be a shame to not learn something from our mistakes.
What are your thoughts?