When Have You Oficcially Redpointed a Route

[pigsteak]

ahab and lander...see the absurdity of it all....we make up acceptable "rules" all the time for this sport. and no one questions it.

next thing ya know there will be permanent bolts on those sandstone faces.

[jenbongo]

I like rjackson's "one for the send, two for safety". I voted for one, but I always clip two - more because I'm OCD, but also for safety. As long as we're sport climbing, you gotta clip one, but if you're soloing, I say go for the whipper . . .

Speaking of "partners" aren't you getting married, Cleveland? to a girl? did that happen yet?

[dbrayack]

My partner's and I were talking last weekend about when you have successfully redpointed a route when one of them pointed out that everyone has there own opinion. I am anxious to hear some people's views on this issue.

What is all comes down to is whatever you want - you're the one that has to live with yourself..if you think tapping and going is fine...well, then check it in your book, log it on your 8a and tell everyone you did it... =)

For me, on a "crucial" RP like something that's at my limit, I'll clip one, then unclip and jump because I feel like having the energy to clip is part of sending the route....but whatever you do personally, that's your perogative.

[ahab]

ahab and lander...see the absurdity of it all....we make up acceptable "rules" all the time for this sport. and no one questions it.

next thing ya know there will be permanent bolts on those sandstone faces.

no way man, on all my redpoints i place bolts/draws on the way up. i would kick some serious arse were i to see someone defacing the rock like that.

wait, now i'm confused...

[Cleveland]

Speaking of "partners" aren't you getting married, Cleveland? to a girl? did that happen yet?

Yeah I'm gettin hitched in October and yeah it's a girl. You still planning on coming down in a couple weeks?

[Lateralus]

I prefer Mauvepoint = do your best climb safe have fun

[rjackson]

..... if ya ain't got the juice to clip, you didn't send.

That's my opinion.

[Meadows]

Pigsteak, that day has already come. I've personally witnessed each of the scenarios you listed.

And I've personally witnessed Pigsteak doing each of those scenarios.

[Crankmas]

[quote="pigsteak" this sport has already been watered down beyond comprehension.

[Crankmas]

allah, this is not a sport carryon- Pigsteak